The standard advice on competitor backlinks is to find every link your competitors have and replicate it. That approach wastes time on links that are not contributing to rankings and misses the ones that actually are.

When we run competitor backlink analysis for clients, the finding that surprises them most is this: competitors are often ranking with far fewer high-quality links than expected. The authority gap is rarely a volume problem. It is almost always a placement problem. A small number of strategically placed, highly relevant links on the right pages is what separates a page ranking in position one from the same page stuck on page two.

This guide covers how to find competitor backlinks, how to analyse them properly, and how to use that analysis to build a smarter outreach strategy rather than a longer replication list.

Why Competitor Backlink Analysis Matters

Competitor backlinks remove the guesswork from link building. Instead of identifying potential link sources from scratch, you start with domains that have already demonstrated willingness to link in your niche.

The value is not just in finding the same links. It is in understanding:

• Which page types are attracting the most links in your niche
• Which domains are consistently linking to multiple competitors
• Where your pages are losing authority relative to pages currently outranking them
• Which competitors built their authority quickly versus slowly over time

That context turns a raw list of referring domains into a prioritised outreach strategy.

Step 1: Identify the Right Competitors to Analyse

Business competitors and SEO competitors are not always the same. The competitors worth analysing are the pages currently outranking you for your target keywords, regardless of whether they are direct business rivals.

How to build the right list:

• Search each of your target commercial keywords and note the top 5 ranking pages
• Include both direct competitors and adjacent sites ranking for the same terms
• Prioritise competitors whose domain authority is closest to yours, not the biggest brands in the category
• Analyse 3 to 5 competitors for each target keyword cluster rather than one broad competitor sweep

Analysing the top-ranked pages for each specific keyword gives you page-level link intelligence, which is more actionable than a broad domain-level comparison.

Step 2: Export and Segment Competitor Link Data

Pull competitor backlink data from Ahrefs or Semrush. Export referring domains rather than individual links. One domain linking multiple times from different pages counts once as a referring domain and that is the unit that matters for authority.

For each competitor page you are targeting, collect:

• Referring domain count to that specific page
• DR and organic traffic of each referring domain
• Anchor text used on the linking page
• Page-level traffic of the linking page itself, not just the domain

This last point is important. A DR 70 domain with a specific linking page that has no organic traffic passes minimal practical value. You want the referring domain data combined with the page-level data for each link source.

Step 3: Identify What Type of Content Is Earning the Links

Before moving to outreach, look at the pages attracting the most links across your competitors and identify what they have in common.

Common patterns across multiple campaigns:

• Original research and industry benchmarks earn links significantly faster than standard blog posts
• Free tools, calculators, and templates attract consistent links from resource roundup pages
• Comparison and alternative pages earn links from review sites, community forums, and niche directories
• Detailed how-to guides earn links from practitioners who reference them as sources

When competitors are earning links through specific content formats rather than aggressive outreach, replicating individual link sources is less valuable than understanding what content intent is driving the acquisition. A well-structured guest posting campaign built around genuinely link-worthy content produces better results than outreach built around standard service pages.

Step 4: Run a Page-Level Gap Analysis

A domain-level gap analysis shows which sites link to competitors but not to you. A page-level gap analysis shows which specific competitor pages are outranking yours and how many more referring domains they have on those exact pages.

The page-level gap is where real opportunities appear:

• If a competitor’s comparison page has 28 referring domains and yours has 4, that specific page is under-supported regardless of overall domain authority
• If a competitor’s integration page is ranking for high-intent queries and your equivalent page has no external links, that is an authority gap with a clear fix
• If a competitor’s resource page earns links from industry blogs, community sites, and niche directories while your equivalent page has none of those sources, those source types become the outreach target

This approach is how we structure the prospecting phase in our managed link building campaigns. The gap analysis at the page level tells us exactly where authority needs to be built and which source types are already proven to link in the niche.

Step 5: Prioritise Opportunities, Not Just Any Gap

Not every competitor link is worth replicating. Running a full competitor link list through an outreach sequence without filtering is the most common way competitor analysis produces low-value work.

Before adding a domain to the outreach list, check:

• Does this domain have genuine organic traffic at both domain and page level?
• Is the topical relevance strong enough that a link from this site would pass real contextual signal?
• Is the linking pattern on this domain editorial or does it look like a link marketplace?
• Does it link to multiple competitors or only one? Domains linking to multiple competitors in your niche are significantly warmer outreach prospects.

Filter down to the domains that pass these checks. The resulting list will be smaller than the full gap report but the outreach will convert at a higher rate and the placements will produce more ranking movement.

For the full quality evaluation framework we apply to every prospect, our guide on high-quality backlinks covers each quality signal in detail.

Step 6: Use the Analysis to Build Links to the Right Pages

The final and most important step is directing the outreach toward the pages that have the gap rather than the pages that are easiest to pitch.

Common mistake: running competitor analysis, identifying that a competitor’s product page has 30 more referring domains than yours, then building all new links to a blog post because the content is easier to pitch to editors.

The right approach:

• Use blog content and link insertions as vehicles to build links that flow authority through internal linking to commercial pages
• Build direct links to comparison pages, alternative pages, and solution pages where editorial context supports it
• Track referring domain growth at the page level for each gap identified in the analysis, not just overall domain growth

Competitor analysis is most useful when it connects directly to the campaign targeting decisions that follow. It is a strategy input, not just a research task.

What Competitor Backlinks Tell You About AI Search Visibility

Competitor backlink analysis also reveals which publications are shaping AI-generated brand associations in your category. Brands consistently cited across multiple authoritative editorial sources build the co-occurrence patterns that AI tools draw on when surfacing recommendations for category queries.

If several competitors appear regularly in the same respected industry publications and review sites, those sources are worth prioritising in outreach. Our brand mentions service addresses this specifically for brands building AI search presence alongside traditional rankings.

Conclusion

Competitor backlink analysis is most useful when it moves beyond “find and replicate” toward understanding what is actually driving competitor rankings at the page level.

The real insight is rarely that competitors have more links overall. It is that they have the right links on the right pages. Identifying those pages, understanding what content types are earning the links, and building a prioritised outreach list from filtered, high-quality gap opportunities is what turns competitor analysis into a campaign that closes ranking gaps rather than just adding to a link count.

Get in touch with Outreach Monks here

Frequently Asked Questions